Why Online Public Schools Are Not a Substitute for Homeschooling - Modern Alternative Mama

Why Online Public Schools Are Not a Substitute for Homeschooling

admin March 3, 2016

Over the last several years, more and more online public schools have cropped up.  I hear advertisements for them frequently on the radio.  They’re supposed to be “the best of both worlds” — keep your kid at home, have flexibility to teach what you want, when you want, but still have a pre-set curriculum to follow and interaction from a certified teacher.  Plus, many online public schools send you materials for free, pay some of your internet bill (because it’s used for school hours), and handle all testing and notifications for you.

What’s not to love?

A lot.

Why Online Public Schools Are Not a Substitute for Homeschooling

First, there are the legal aspects.

For the purposes of the law, online public school is public school.  It is not homeschooling, and is not regulated the same way at all.  The online public school is basically a charter school.  It does things a bit differently than public schools (i.e. the flexibility to have students mostly at home), but it’s otherwise subject to the same rules and laws that the public schools are.  There is compulsory attendance, testing requirements, etc.

Oh, attendance?  How do you prove attendance when you’re schooling from home?  Can’t you just do it on your own time, as long as you get through most of it?  No.

Online public schools vary in the number of “active” hours they require.  “Active” hours are the time that students are required to be in front of the computer, directly interacting with their teacher(s) or other classmates.  Some are only required to be active for about 5 – 10 hours per week.  Others are required to be active for several hours each day — that is, basically the same hours that they would have been in a public school classroom.  It’s basically just “school at home.”

If a kid does not show up for these active hours, they are considered truant.  The parents will get a phone call from the teacher, asking where they were, and they may be required to make up these hours later.  If they are truant for enough hours, they can get kicked out.

Online public schools are also clear that they are in charge of your child’s education — you serve as a “coach” to make sure that your child does what the school wants you to.  (K12, a popular option, actually refers to parents as “learning coaches,” and states that they must support their child’s learning for 3 – 5 hours each day.)

Online public school students are required to complete 25 hours per week of instruction.  Families are required to log their hours each day to prove “attendance” — and insufficient hours can result in truancy charges.  Students are also strongly discouraged from taking any family vacations or doing any traveling during school times, just like public school students — unless they will take their work with them and continue to log hours as usual.

Students are required to take all state standardized tests.  These are done at a physical location, and students will be assigned a place, date, and time to take these tests.  Families in my area have told me that if you opt out of standardized tests for more than 2 years in a row (which is allowed, but discouraged, by the public schools), that online public schools will kick you out.


It’s not homeschooling.  Not even a little bit.

But I Thought Online Public Schools Were Flexible!

That depends on your definition of flexible.

Can your kid stay home and do work in his PJs?  Yes.  Can your kid do school from 10 AM to 5 PM instead of 8 – 3?  Yes, usually (unless they have a “class connect” meeting with their teacher earlier).  Can your kid do extra activities above and beyond regular schooling more easily, or during day time hours?  Yes.

…but.  You don’t have any say over the curriculum that is taught.  Your child is expected to have a certain number of hours of attendance.  Your child is expected to be present online frequently during regular school hours.  Your child is tested  often, and must take all required standardized tests.

Let’s not kid ourselves.  It’s public school, done at home.  Exactly that, and nothing more.

Online Public Schools are Better…Or Not?

I have a few friends who are in online public schools, and who have grown increasingly frustrated with them.

One public school (physical, regular public school) has a standard that students must read at 50 words per minute to pass third grade.  Yet, my friend’s daughter, in an online public school, has been told she needs to read at 75 words per minute to pass second grade, and 92 words per minute to pass third!  (An average adult reads at 120 – 130 words per minute.)

What’s even worse about this is that it only measures reading speed — not comprehension.  A child could memorize words through a whole-word approach, and say them all in the required time, without any understanding of what they just read.  And they would pass the test.  That’s insane — of course comprehension matters more than speed!  But, not in this school.

Semi-recently, a friend’s child was tested on reading speed.  Despite meeting the target goal in some of the tests (they have the child read 3 short passages), the child’s average did not meet the goal, so the parent was told that their child needed to be in “remedial” reading classes — every day, online.  When my friend said that wasn’t possible because they also participate in activities and events outside the home, the teacher told them that didn’t matter, the child was required to attend.  Online public school comes first, and everything else comes second.

If You Want to Homeschool, Then Homeschool

I understand.

A lot of parents want to homeschool, but feel very hesitant.  They aren’t sure where to start.  They don’t know what curriculum is best.  They’re afraid they’ll end up with gaps in their child’s education or they will somehow “mess them up.”

Even parents who have moved past those fears still often want “a plan.”  They want someone or something to guide them in what to do.  They like the idea of a boxed curriculum that comes with instructions on what to teach, when to teach it, and how to teach it.  They want some accountability, for fear that they’ll get too busy with life, younger siblings, etc. and they won’t keep up with their child’s education.

Still, other parents worry about the cost of homeschooling.  They look at pre-packaged curricula that may cost hundreds of dollars.  They hear about all the activities, classes, and field trips some students do and think about the cost involved in those.  They feel like there’s no way they can afford it all, and give their children a good-enough education.  Parents, after all, want the best for their kids.

For many parents, online public school sounds like an attractive option.  It covers the first concern — they don’t have to worry about where to start, or choosing a curriculum, or messing anything up.  They are told exactly what their kids are learning and when.  They don’t have to worry about the second concern because they have accountability to the school and a plan from the school.  And they don’t have to worry about the third concern because it’s tuition-free and subsidies are even available for computers, internet, and materials.

I get it.  I really do.

But think about what you are trading for all of that.

  • Inability to choose your child’s curriculum
  • Inability to skip lessons/materials that don’t work for your child’s learning style, or family’s beliefs
  • Inability to opt out of standardized testing
  • Inability to opt out of other regular testing
  • Required online lesson times, that are not optional or flexible (the teacher is “teaching” many students and can’t change the schedule to accommodate one)
  • Little flexibility in school hours/days

If you really want to homeschool, don’t be lured by the promises that online schools make.  There’s a place for them, for parents who really want their kids to go to public school but who maybe have custody arrangements where kids are in two different districts at different times, or who have special medical needs, or who are being bullied and need a reprieve.  But don’t kid yourself — they are public schools, so only use them if you want public school.

In future posts, we’ll explore how to get over your fears and really explore if homeschooling is for you — I know how overwhelming that can be for first-time parents!

Have you ever used an online public school?  What was your experience?

Confused about vaccines?

Get our FREE no-nonsense vaccine guide. Answer your questions with rational, fact-based information instead of fear.

This is the writings of:



  1. We tried an online school and it was horrid. They required so much work, it was insane. Trying to get everything done for two kids in grades 3 and 5 would take all day. They hated school more than when they were in a brick and mortar school. And you’re right about flexibility. My oldest want to be able to jump around to different chapters in his science book, but, no, you have to go in the order they have on the syllabus. We ended up not finishing out the year with them and decided to do actual homeschooling because the frustration and exhaustion just wasn’t worth it.


  2. We’ve had a very positive experience with our online public school. I’ve had many “lectures” from other homeschool parents telling me that what we we are doing is not homeschooling, which I find ironic. Isn’t the point that we choose to homeschool for our own reasons? We have easy access to teachers, who are mostly wonderful. The structure and sequential lessons work for her, and as someone who is planning to enter public high school we are confident that she’ll have been ex posed to all her required courses and then some. Maybe it’s not for everyone, but it is a wonderful option.


  3. Our experience with high school courses from an online public school high school program has been excellent. We chose the homeschool track instead of the full-time track, which lets us retain control of his courses, but still meets NCAA requirements for sports for colleges. Our child is required to have the usual homeschool annual evaluation for progress – not necessarily the state standardized tests. Until he is ready for SATs/ACTs, we have chosen the Stanford Achievement Test, which is the same test he’s taken since 4th grade.

    The one-on-one teacher relationships my son has developed in each of his online courses are very positive and nurturing. They speak on the phone at least once each week and email regularly. They also call and correspond with me. The coursework fits nicely around his heavy sports schedule and he can work any time – not just during school hours. While there are regularly scheduled meetings with his teachers at the end of each unit, these are 15 minutes long and are just conversations about how things are going with gentle quizzing about the subject matter. There is a comprehensive end of course online test, but it is well thought out and hits the highlights.

    After a grueling semester in a private brick & mortar high school, we have found this method of taking selective sequential courses from this curriculum has greatly alleviated stress, supplied the freedom he needs to pursue his dreams and satisfied us that he is getting what he needs for high school and college.


  4. Thank you a million times over !!! My exact felling, I felt like I was judged and had done something wrong once we had enrolled, however I should of listened to my intuition once we had the phone interview!!!
    Any suggestions on a program to use for my daughter that will be freshman this year ??? This will be her second year to homeschool, I have just not found any one program I am
    Thrilled about !!! Thank you for caring enough to post ❤️


  5. Aimee and Katherine,can you tell me which program you used? You do not mention the name of the online school so it is difficult to compare.


  6. Ariel, I am looking for program guidance as well. Did you ever hear back from Kate? If so, what program did she recommend?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Hi, I’m Kate.  I love medical freedom, sharing natural remedies, developing real food recipes, and gentle parenting. My goal is to teach you how to live your life free from Big Pharma, Big Food, and Big Government by learning about herbs, cooking, and sustainable practices.

I’m the author of Natural Remedies for Kids and the owner and lead herbalist at EarthleyI hope you’ll join me on the journey to a free and healthy life!

Meet My Family
Love our content? Sigh for our weekly newsletter and get our FREE Vaccine Guide!